Dining & Restaurants

A Date Night at Nonno's Ristorante

We went to Nonno's Ristorante in Murrieta for Wednesday date night: a salad, two entrées, dessert, and a bottle of wine for $88. It was, and always is, a truly amazing epicurean experience — with a teaser for Chef Luigi's new Temecula chophouse.

By Jason Gailliot and Windy Ciucki, Realtors, McDermott Realty Group · November 14, 2026

  • Italian
  • Murrieta
  • Date Night
A slice of layered chocolate cake with whipped cream, raspberries, and mint at Nonno's Ristorante, with two glasses of red wine.

Chocolate cake to finish a Wednesday date night at Nonno's. Photo: Jason Gailliot.

There are restaurants you visit, and there are restaurants you return to because the evening still feels like an occasion. Nonno's Ristorante, on Murrieta Hot Springs Road, has always been the second kind of place for us. It was, and it always is, a truly amazing epicurean experience.

We went on a Wednesday, which at Nonno's is date night. The official prix-fixe, listed on the restaurant's current menu, is straightforward and generous: a salad to share, two entrées, a dessert, and a bottle of wine, for $88 a couple. (Specials change, and the kitchen notes that the menu is subject to availability and price; it is worth calling ahead at (951) 461-7998, or reserving online, to confirm what is being poured and plated that week.) What arrived at the table was not a compromise version of dinner. It was Nonno's, in full.

Chef Luigi's table

The room is Chef Luigi Mazzaro's. He was born in Naples, Italy, in a culture where food, family, and hospitality are not separate ideas, and he has built his cooking around the bold flavors, simple ingredients, and older Italian traditions he grew up with. The restaurant itself is named for Nonno — grandfather — who was born in Naples in 1929. In his honor, Chef Luigi has spent more than a decade at this Murrieta address cooking with care for ingredients, including organic produce when it is in season, and with a kind of hospitality that still feels personal.

That story now has a second chapter, which we will come to. First, the dinner.

A Caesar, a Lodi Pinot, and a plate of pasta

The date-night salads are a choice of a mixed green or a Caesar. Ours was the Caesar: cold, crisp romaine, croutons, a proper shower of Parmigiano, black pepper, and a dressing that clung instead of pooling. It is a simple plate, which is precisely why it is a useful test of a kitchen. This one passed.

A Caesar salad and a bottle of Maggio Family Vineyards 2024 Pinot Noir at Nonno's Ristorante.

A Caesar to share, and the California Pinot Noir poured that Wednesday — a Maggio Family Vineyards 2024. Photo: Jason Gailliot.

With it came a bottle of Maggio Family Vineyards 2024 Pinot Noir. Maggio is a Lodi, California, winery, not a Temecula label, and it is not named on Nonno's published wine list — the Wednesday pairing is listed simply as a California Pinot Noir, and pours can change. What we can say is what was on the table that night: a medium-bodied, fruit-forward Pinot, already open in the glasses, doing what a date-night red should do beside a Caesar and a pasta.

The pasta was a bowl of spaghetti in a light, savory sauce, with artichoke, capers, a drift of grated Parmigiano, cracked pepper, and a sprig of thyme. We will not dress it with a menu name we could not confirm — kitchens run specials, and plates are not always the printed line — but the cooking was confident and clear. The artichoke was tender, the capers gave the sauce a little salt and lift, and the thyme was not a garnish so much as a scent you met before the first bite. It is the kind of pasta that makes you slow down.

Spaghetti with artichokes, capers, Parmigiano, and thyme at Nonno's Ristorante.

Spaghetti with artichoke, capers, Parmigiano, and thyme. Photo: Jason Gailliot.

That is the register of this kitchen in general. The everyday menu is broader than any one Wednesday: mussels in pinot grigio, burrata and salame, homemade meatballs, a carpaccio of sirloin; then pastas such as fettuccine Bolognese, rigatoni San Remo, lobster ravioli with shrimp, spaghetti alle vongole. There is organic chicken in the usual Italian keys — Parmigiana, Marsala, and a lemon-caper carciofi — and a short list of steaks and fish. Chef Luigi's wine recommendations are printed right on the dishes, which tells you something about how he wants the meal to go.

The list itself is a boutique one, just as the restaurant describes it: Italy and California, including local Temecula bottles from Robert Renzoni Vineyards, and a small set of wines Chef Luigi has had made from estate-grown Paso Robles fruit and bottled under Nonno's own names — a cabernet, a Sangiovese, a red blend. Thursdays, most bottles are half off. For a wider look at tables in this valley, see our dining guide.

Then the cake

Dessert on date night is a choice among tiramisu, cheesecake, and chocolate cake. Ours was the chocolate cake: a tall, layered wedge, dark and pale, with a glossy top, a swirl of cream, raspberries, and a sprig of mint, the last of the red wine still in the glasses. It looks like a celebration even when the occasion is only Wednesday. It tasted like one, too.

And now, Mazzaro's

Chef Luigi has just opened a second restaurant, Mazzaro's Italian Chophouse, on Nicole Lane in Temecula, near Promenade Temecula. If Nonno's is the neighborhood ristorante, Mazzaro's is the more meat-forward room — "Italian heart, chophouse craft," as the kitchen puts it. One side of the menu is still unmistakably his: focaccia from the oven, antipasti, pasta made by hand each morning, carbonara, linguine with clams, risotto with porcini and guanciale, lobster ravioli, a cioppino. The other side is the grill: USDA Prime and Snake River Farms beef — a ribeye, a New York, a filet, a porterhouse — along with a Berkshire pork chop, a rack of lamb, and a mixed grigliata, each with a sauce and a side. From the cold water, there is Chilean sea bass, Alaskan halibut, king salmon, branzino, a lobster tail.

We have not sat down to review Mazzaro's yet. We will. Consider this a teaser, and a promise: the new room is on our list, and we will come back to it in The LuxRE Journal soon. For now, the reservation line is (951) 693-4868, at 41789 Nicole Lane, Suite B1, Temecula.

The kind of evening you keep

We keep going back to Nonno's because the cooking is still serious, the room is still warm, and a Wednesday can still feel like a date. The $88 special is a genuine invitation, not a lesser menu, and the rest of the card — the pastas, the wine, the cake — is the work of a chef who has been at this a long time and has not grown careless.

If you go, make a reservation, ask what is pouring with date night, and give the evening the time it deserves. Nonno's Ristorante is at 40711 Murrieta Hot Springs Road in Murrieta, (951) 461-7998, nonnosristorante.com.

It was wonderful. It always is.

— Jason and Windy

All posts

More in Dining & Restaurants

All Dining & Restaurants entries
The 1985 pizza at Angelo's Brick Oven with pepperoni, meatball and mushrooms

Dining & Restaurants · November 14, 2026

Calamari and the 1985 at Angelo's

A shared plate of calamari and the 1985, wood-fired, at Angelo's Brick Oven Pizzeria in Wildomar, and the Sicilian story behind every pie.

Dining & Restaurants · November 14, 2026

Ceviche and Skirt Steak at Bolero

We went to Bolero Restaurante at Europa Village for the ceviche and the skirt steak — both, as always, beyond amazing — and to tell the stories of owner Dan Stephenson and Executive Chef Hany Ali.

Private valuation

Request a private home valuation.

No obligation, no automated estimate.